Inside the Mind of a Kurdish Hostage Negotiator

Psychology of Hostage Negotiation

By Jessica L. Walton

The voice on the telephone delivered an ultimatum: unless Kurdish forces withdrew from a besieged Syrian city by nine o’clock the following evening, two kidnapped men would be beheaded, and their severed heads delivered in a box.

On the receiving end was a Kurdish fighter who would eventually become an experienced hostage negotiator. This time, the lives at stake were those of his own brothers.

His commanders instructed him not to concede to the threat. The Kurdish forces had captured enemy fighters of their own, and his leadership believed the jihadists would not risk executing their prisoners. Despite the agonizing pressure of knowing his brothers’ lives hung in the balance, he stood firm. The deadline passed, the Kurdish forces remained in position, and his brothers survived.

For the man who goes by the nom de guerre, or kod-nav, Heval Shehab, the episode offered an early lesson in the brutal psychology of negotiating with jihadist organizations: understanding what an adversary wants—and what he stands to lose—can be as important as understanding what he threatens to do.

Earlier this year, I became friends with Aram Aqil, a talented Kurdish youth educator and journalist now based in Germany. Several years ago, Aram was kidnapped by ISIS while reporting from the front lines for Kurdish television station Rûdaw TV, and it was Shehab who secured his release. The two men remain close friends and speak regularly to this day—a testament to the humanity that can emerge from even the most inhumane circumstances.

That friendship also made our interview possible. Shehab joined me by WhatsApp video from Rojava, northeastern Syria, with Aram generously serving as our interpreter. Given that my Arabic is barely at kindergarten level and my Kurmanji is virtually nonexistent, his assistance was invaluable.

Over the course of our conversation, Shehab described years of negotiating hostage releases, prisoner exchanges, and the recovery of human remains during Syria’s civil war and the campaign against ISIS. His experiences offer a rare battlefield perspective on a dilemma that continues to confront Western governments and counterterrorism professionals:

How do negotiators save lives without strengthening the organizations responsible for taking them?

The answer lies in understanding the psychology behind those demands, the hidden sources of leverage, and the consequences of any agreement reached.

Understanding What Makes a Jihadist Tick

Popular portrayals of jihadist fighters emphasize ideological fanaticism and a willingness to die for a religious cause. Yet individual motivations can be considerably more complicated. For negotiators confronting terrorist organizations, distinguishing ideological conviction from personal ambition, financial incentives, or self-preservation can mean the difference between a breakthrough and a fatal miscalculation.

In contrast to the image of unwavering religious commitment, Shehab recalled encountering fighters whose loyalties proved surprisingly shallow.

Relatively few of the fighters he encountered demonstrated a deep understanding of the ideology they claimed to defend. Many renounced ISIS after capture, expressing regret or abandoning their former allegiance. Others appeared motivated by money or opportunities for sexual exploitation rather than religious conviction. He considered some of the youngest fighters, particularly those aged 14 to 17, among the most dangerous. In his experience, they displayed strikingly little remorse for their violence.

Shehab’s observations underscore a critical challenge: An armed group’s ideology does not necessarily explain the motivations of every individual acting on its behalf.

And the psychological battle doesn’t necessarily end with the captors and their hostages. It can extend to the audiences watching from thousands of miles away.

When Hostages Become Weapons of Psychological Warfare

In a recent Small Wars Journal essay examining Hamas’s exploitation of Israeli hostages, former U.S. Army psychological operations specialist John Kirbow describes how captors use psychological warfare to manipulate public perceptions and build support for their cause.

He cites the case of Israeli hostage Danielle Aloni, who was kidnapped with her five-year-old daughter. While in captivity, Aloni wrote a letter expressing appreciation for Hamas, which the terrorist group publicly circulated. Only after her release did she reveal that she had written it under severe duress, out of fear for her and her daughter’s lives.

By then, the letter had already helped foster an impression of Hamas’s supposed compassion, illustrating how captors can exploit hostages not only as bargaining chips but also as instruments of propaganda to shape the narrative surrounding the crisis.

While captors exploit psychology to manipulate public perceptions, negotiators must also understand the psychological forces driving their adversaries. Former FBI lead international kidnapping negotiator Chris Voss offers a useful framework for doing so. In his bestselling book Never Split the Difference, Voss argues that emotions, perceptions, and the need for control often shape negotiations more than rational calculations.

Central to his approach is tactical empathy: understanding and acknowledging an adversary’s perspective without agreeing with it. Techniques such as mirroring language, identifying underlying emotions, and asking carefully calibrated questions can reveal motivations that might otherwise remain concealed.

Former U.S. Special Presidential Envoy for Hostage Affairs Roger D. Carstens has similarly emphasized the importance of understanding an adversary’s interests. Speaking at a Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) event in 2025, Carstens argued that empathy and respect are essential even when dealing with hostile counterparts. In his experience, approaching negotiations with humility and seeking to understand an adversary’s objectives can improve the chances of securing a hostage’s release.

Although Carstens’s work frequently involved Americans detained by foreign governments rather than jihadist organizations, the underlying principle is relevant to both: Understanding an adversary does not mean excusing his actions. It means identifying the incentives and vulnerabilities that influence his decisions.

The Psychology of Leverage

Understanding an adversary is only part of the equation. Negotiators must also contend with threats, deadlines, and psychological pressure.

Shehab’s experience with his brothers illustrates the stakes. His commanders believed the enemy fighter they held gave them sufficient leverage to resist the captors’ demands. Their assessment proved correct, but such decisions carry enormous uncertainty.

Shehab described hostage recovery as a humanitarian responsibility, while insisting that emotion should never govern decisions. As he put it, “you’re bargaining for human life.” He also emphasized the importance of “never showing weakness.” That philosophy may seem at odds with Voss’s tactical empathy, but both approaches require negotiators to recognize emotions without surrendering control of their responses.

Voss explores this dynamic through what he calls the Black Swan: a hidden piece of information that can fundamentally change a negotiation.

For Shehab, that information often came from relationships established long before the war. He had numerous personal connections to Arab tribal leaders, traders, and families across northeastern Syria. Some of these connections included relatives of ISIS fighters. When the war broke out and the region became a boiling cauldron of rival factions, his familiarity with the region and its people helped him identify who held influence, whom he could trust, and what particular commanders valued—providing leverage that might not have been apparent from their public demands.

One detail from our conversation disturbed me, for personal reasons: Kurdish negotiators generally sought exchanges of one captive for one captured fighter, or at most two. As an American-Israeli citizen, I couldn’t help but think back to October 2011, when I was living in Jerusalem and Israel released 1,027 Palestinian prisoners in exchange for a single Israeli soldier, Gilad Shalit. The agreement secured Shalit’s freedom but fueled intense debate in Israel over whether such large-scale exchanges encouraged future hostage-taking.

Regardless, the contrast between the Kurdish and Israeli cases illustrates that leverage isn’t simply about determining what an adversary will accept. It’s also about knowing where to draw the line: what price a government or armed force is prepared to pay, and what unintended consequences might result from that decision.

The Price of a Human Life

Even successful hostage negotiations can trigger a cascade of unforeseen repercussions, with costs that are difficult to anticipate, much less calculate.

In August 2026, Reuters reported that United Nations experts had linked an estimated $50 million ransom paid in 2025 to secure hostage’s release in Mali to the financing of al-Qaeda-linked operations across West Africa. The funds reportedly supported weapons purchases, recruitment, logistics, and an expanding militant offensive, with potentially deadly consequences for civilians and security forces across the region.

Herein lies a troubling paradox: a payment intended to save one life can fund violence against many others.

Shehab said Kurdish negotiators generally rejected monetary ransom demands, relying instead on exchanges involving captured fighters or human remains. In his assessment, paying armed groups would have strengthened their enemies while placing crippling economic pressure on Kurdish communities.

Yet prisoner exchanges introduce dilemmas of their own. Releasing a captured militant may save a hostage’s life while returning an experienced fighter to an armed organization.

In a July 2025 interview on The Jedburgh Podcast, Carstens discussed precisely this dilemma in the context of Israeli negotiations with Hamas. The competing demands of hostage families and national security officials, he explained, ultimately require political leaders to accept responsibility for the risks associated with a deal. Carstens also distinguished between negotiations involving foreign governments and those involving terrorist organizations, noting that U.S. policy places tighter restrictions on concessions to terrorist hostage-takers.

Ultimately, there are no easy formulas for resolving such choices. The imperative to recover a hostage must be weighed against the potential consequences for future victims and civilian populations.

When the Battlefield Undermines the Negotiating Table

Even when both sides are willing to negotiate, the operational environment can undermine success.

Shehab described negotiations conducted across extensive front lines, minefields, and contested territory. Communications could break down, intermediaries could change, and armed units operating nearby did not always understand that negotiations were underway.

He recalled one incident in which two designated intermediaries were mistakenly killed before reaching a meeting. In another, a negotiator was killed after stepping on a mine in an area where the danger had not been adequately communicated. The negotiation collapsed as a result.

These episodes illustrate how failures of coordination can quickly unravel an agreement.

While Shehab’s experiences expose the battlefield consequences of failed coordination, Carstens’s work illustrates the diplomatic and institutional challenges of preventing such failures at the strategic level. Both underscore the complexities of hostage recovery, which often requires cooperation among governments, intelligence agencies, military forces, and intermediaries whose interests may diverge and whose access to critical information may be limited.

For U.S. special operations and intelligence professionals working with local partners, both perspectives reinforce the importance of combining intelligence capabilities with sustained relationships and cultural understanding. Knowing an adversary’s intentions is valuable; knowing who can influence his decisions—and whether an agreement can actually be carried out—may prove decisive.

Lessons Beyond the Negotiating Table

The experiences in Syria, Israel, and Mali demonstrate that hostage negotiation is neither purely diplomatic nor a contest of wills. It is a complex interaction involving psychology, intelligence, cultural understanding, operational coordination, and difficult moral calculations.

Voss and Carstens offer insights into the psychological discipline required to negotiate with hostile adversaries. Shehab’s experiences provide a battlefield perspective shaped by years of direct engagement with jihadist organizations, including negotiating for his own family members.

Together, their perspectives suggest that successful hostage recovery requires more than identifying what captors demand. It requires understanding why they demand it, what they fear losing, who can influence their decisions, and what the consequences of an agreement might be.

For the families waiting for a loved one’s return, those calculations are deeply personal. And for the professionals responsible for bringing hostages home, the challenge remains the same: finding a way to save lives without creating the conditions for more to be taken.

**********

Author. Jessica L. Walton is a communications strategist and writer in the defense industry based in the Washington, D.C. area. She is also a writing instructor for professionals in government, national security, technology, and engineering. A former IDF soldier and security analyst, she specializes in information operations and asymmetric warfare. Learn more at www.jessicawaltonwriter.com.

Image. ChatGPT.